Blog

goDown

Jury finds former Metro-North conductor unlawfully arrested by MTA cops, gets $1M in court


Key Points
The jury found the NITA police officers unlawfully arrested former Metro-North condttctor Thomas Moran and violated his free speech rights. Moran suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder.

A former Metro-North conductor won a nearly $r million verdict Monday against three MTA police officers who forced him to the ground and handcuffed him during a violent confrontation in Grand Central Terminal in zot7.

Thomas Moran has been unable to return to worl< since August 2ot7 when he was charged with assaulting an officer and resisting arrest after requesting the officers’help with a wheelchair passenger who refused to leave the train. Moran sued in zor9.

A jury in U.S. District Court in Manhattan awarded Morzn, 54, nearly $Boo,ooo in compensation for unlawful arrest and violations of his free speech and another $r8o,ooo for punitive damages for the actions of three MTA police officers, Nicholas Strype, Douglas Cohen and Jason Nandoo. The jury rejected unlawful arrest claims for a fourth officer.

Criminal charges against Moran were dismissed by a judge in February zor8

Moran declined to comment. His lawyer, George Cahill, said he was too exhausted from the weeklong trial.

“Tom Moran and his family are very happy that he was vindicated for this unnecessary and unlawful misconduct by the MTA Police,” Cahill said.

A spokesman for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority said its attorneys are “assessing post-verdict options. ”

Brutality: Conductors union calls for firing, arrest of MTA cops, citing police brutality

Charges dropped Assault charges dropped vs. Metro-North conductor in altercation with MTA cops

Clash with cops led Moran to sue MTA Police

Moran’s arrest, captured by MTA surveillance cameras, came during a period of heightened tension between Metro-North conductors and MTA police.

After the incident, Moran’s union called for the officers’ arrest and accused them of brutality The officers countered, saying Moran yelled and cursed at them when they tried to intervene in a passenger dispute.

In the video, officers take the burly Moran to the ground and handcuffhim while another stands nearby holding a German Shepherd on a leash. Passengers stroll by, one appearing to capture the arrest on his phone.

Moran said he went to the officers for help after a disorderly passenger refused to exit an

early-morning northbound New Haven Line train when he told him it would not stop at re5th Street in Harlem.

Northbound trains pick up passengers at rz5th Street but don’t allow them to exit there.

Moran said he was trying to direct the passenger to a Hudson Line train that stopped at 125th Street.

Moran was jailed for r4 hours after the altercation and has not returned to work. Cahill, his lawyer, said he suffers from post-traumatic stress.

“Basically I got attacked for doing my job,” Moran said in February zot8, after Manhattan prosecutors announced they could not prove the criminal charges of assault and resisting arrest.

Cahill said it was notable that the jury awarded punitive damages for each of the three officers.

“The jury had to find that the conduct was so extreme and outrageous that actual compensatory damages are inadequate to punish the wrongful conduct,” Cahill said.

Edward Valente, a conductor and the general chairman of Moran’s union, the Association of Commuter Rail Employees, said Moran has been unable to return to his old life since the arrest.

“I am very happy that he was finally exonerated of all charges and awarded damages but you can never put a number on the trauma and the emotional suffering Tom has had to endure,” Valente said. “I pray that Tom and his famrly can one day put this ugly incident behind them.

What is the officers’ version of their interaction with Moran?

In pre-trial depositions, the officers said Moran cursed them, calling them o’useless” after he approached them at a gate at the top of the platform asking for help.

When they asked for his identification Moran refused and walked back along the platform where his r:o7 a.m. train was waiting to depart, they say.

In his deposition, Strype, one of the officers, said before the arrest he and another officer confronted the passenger while he was sleeping in his wheelchair in the terminal.

The passenger said he was headed to 125th Street and showed him a ticket. Strype said he couldn’t understand why Moran would not allow the man on the train.

“I eventually told him he had a valid ticket and he just didn’t want to hear what any of us had to say because he was too busy being angry and unruly that he just continued to walk away after every time we said something,” Strype said during a November zorg deposition.

Moran’s lawsuit admits he told an MTApolice officer “You guys are useless” after being told they couldn’t help.

As he walked back to the train, one of the officers yelled “Why don’t you jus-t d9 your job”‘ “l am doing my job,” Moran responded. “Why don’t you do your job?”

He was taken to the ground moments later.

  • $10.8 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Conductor wrongful death case. (Avery v. Metro-North RR).
  • $8 Million settlement for an Amtrak Trackman who sustained a crushed leg. (Cevasco v. National Railroad Passenger Corp.).
  • $7 Million settlement for a Metro-North Foreman whose legs were amputated. (Renert v. Metro-North RR).
  • $5.8 Million settlement for an Amtrak Conductor who sustained a head injury. (Fitzpatrick v. National Railroad Passenger Corp.).
  • $5.5 Million settlement for a Metro-North Machinist wrongful death case. (Pieger v. Metro-North RR).
  • $4.3 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Conductor wrongful death case. (Ard v. Metro-North RR)
  • $2.57 Million Verdict for an Amtrak Conductor who sustained a back injury. (Pace v. National Railroad Passenger Corp.).
  • $2.5 Million Settlement for a Metro-North employee who sustained a serious head injury.
  • Settled for a Confidential Sum for a Massachusetts Bay Commuter Railroad Company Trackman wrongful death case. (Macaulay v. Massachusetts Bay Commuter Railroad Company.)
  • $6.250 Million Verdict in 2023 which was later reduced to $2.1 Million for a Metro-North Structural Welder/Ironworker who sustained head and neck injuries and has returned to work. (Torres v. Metro-North RR).
  • $2 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Lineman who sustained an electrical burn (Curly v. Metro-North RR).
  • $2 Million Settlement in 2020 for a Providence & Worcester Railroad Company Conductor who sustained a serious head injury and returned to work for another RR as an Engineer. (Scarpa v. Providence & Worcester Railroad Company.)
  • $2 Million Settlement for a Metro-North Conductor who sustained a fractured leg.
    Settled for a Confidential Sum in 2019 an Amtrak Lineman involving an electrocution causing a permanent occupational disability. (Anderson v. National Railroad Passenger Corp.).
  • $1.85 Million Verdict for an Amtrak Ticket Agent who was assaulted. (Schneider v. National Railroad Passenger Corp.)
  • Compensatory and punitive damages Verdicts and subsequently settled for $1.8 Million in 2023 for a Metro-North
  • Conductor who suffered Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. (Moran v. Metropolitan Transportation Authority).
  • $1.69 Million Settlement for an Amtrak Supervisor who was shot by an employee. (Cornelius v. National Railroad Passenger Corp.)
  • $1.65 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Lineman who sustained foot and ankle injuries. (Keating v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1.65 Million Verdict for a Metro-North TA Employee who sustained an Open Tibia Fracture to his left leg. (Rivera v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1.54 Million Verdict for an Amtrak General Foreman who sustained a herniated disc in his lower back. (Brady v. National Railroad Passenger Corporation).
  • $1.45 Million Verdict for a Construction Worker who sustained a left hip injury. (Quintiliani v. National Railroad Passenger Corporation).
  • $1.42 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Machinist who sustained a fractured rib and a herniated disc. (Hall v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1.4 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Mechanical Gang Foreman who sustained burns from an explosion of steam on an engine. (Berry v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1.4 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Carpenter Foreman who sustained a back injury. (Kendall v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1.3 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Signal Trainee Maintainer who sustained a back injury from a slip and fall. (Moran v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1.2 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Signal Maintainer who sustained a back injury and post-concussion syndrome. (Manes v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1.2 Million Verdict for a Metro-North Trackman who sustained crushed legs. (Murillo v. Metro-North RR).
  • $1 Million Settlement for a Metro-North Trackman who sustained burns from pot welding and subsequently returned to work. (Burke v. Metro-North RR).

find yourself a Railroad Law Attorney | Call 800-654-7245

CALL OR EMAIL US TODAY TO GET STARTED

If you are a railroad worker who has been injured on the job, you need a lawyer who understands the complicated FELA claims process. Find out how we can help you receive the compensation you deserve.

Protecting Injured Railroad Workers,
Passengers And Families
40 years of experience

New Haven Office

43 Trumbull Street
New Haven, CT 06510
Toll Free: 800-654-7245

Phone: 203-777-1000
Fax: 203-865-5904
directions

Boston Office

470 Atlantic Avenue, 4th Floor
Boston, MA 02210

Phone: (617) 217-2920
directions

arla

New York Office

Chrysler Building
405 Lexington Avenue, 26th Floor
New York, NY 10174

Toll Free: 800-654-7245
Phone: 212-453-7300
directions

connect with us